Limitations of the Consumer Price Index (CPI)

Limitations of the Consumer Price Index (CPI)

One of the most fundamental and crucial economic indicators used to gauge inflation is the consumer price index (CPI). In addition to the United States, almost every other developed country also uses a CPI.

The publication of monthly CPI figures always has a big impact on the financial markets. Numbers that are unexpectedly high or low can ruin an investment. The CPI is one of many consumer price indexes that the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) releases each month.

The CPI is far from ideal as a gauge of either inflation or the cost of living, while being commonly cited as the main indication of inflation. It contains several flaws that are inherently bad.
Its accuracy has come under increasing fire.

For instance, the CPI maintained to display a fairly low inflation rate during a period when energy expenses soared by more than 50% and the cost of some of the most popular supermarket goods jumped by around 30%.

In contrast, several measures of consumers’ purchasing power revealed a sharp rise in the cost of living.

Here, we examine some of the CPI’s shortcomings and the reasons behind the ongoing debate.

CPI Basket

A weighted index of consumer goods purchases is the CPI.
It might serve as a reasonably accurate gauge of changes in the prices of the particular items in its basket. The CPI’s consideration of consumer products does not, however, encompass all economic output or consumption. Therefore, the CPI is fundamentally defective as a measure of the state of the economy.
At the moment, the basket of products consists of commonplace foods and drinks like cereal, milk, and coffee. It also covers housing costs, clothing prices, furnishings for bedrooms, toy costs, medical care costs, and costs associated with transportation. The price of museum entry is likewise acceptable for inclusion.
Expenses for communication and education are also included in the contents of the basket. Additionally, the government keeps track of seemingly unrelated things like tobacco, haircuts, and funerals.
However, the items in the basket only represent a small portion of all the products and services that are offered to consumers. The CPI might therefore have certain blind spots.

Replaceable Items

The fact that the CPI does not take the effects of substitution into account is one issue with the index that economists have pointed out and which the Bureau of Labor Statistics freely acknowledges.
According to economic realities, when a product’s price increases dramatically, many customers choose to choose less expensive substitutes. For instance, people might choose to purchase store brands rather than name brands. Or they could choose to purchase normal gasoline rather than premium.

This widespread practice cannot be taken into account by the CPI. Instead, it gives statistics based on the supposition that people will keep purchasing the same volume of progressively costlier things.

Quality of the Product Has Improved

Another flaw in the CPI is novelty and innovation. Prior to being recognized as a staple of consumer spending through time, products are not included in the CPI’s basket of goods. Therefore, even if new products might account for sizable consumer spending, they might not yet be taken into account in the CPI calculation.

Any pure price index has a problem since it ignores changes in the quality of the goods consumers buy. Due to material improvements in the product’s quality and the functions it fulfills, consumers may actually benefit from acquiring a product whose price has increased.

The CPI, on the other hand, lacks a standard for quantifying such quality improvements, and as a result, it merely reflects price increases without taking into account any additional benefits to consumers.

Concentration on Urban Consumption

The CPI was designed with metropolitan consumers’ purchasing patterns in mind. It has frequently been criticized for being unreliable in measuring both the costs of items and the consumer spending patterns in more suburban or rural locations.

Even while cities are the hubs of economic activity, a sizable portion of the population still resides outside of these places, where costs may be higher.
The fact that the CPI does not offer distinct reports on various demographic groupings is a more general criticism.

Subtle Inflation

Expenses that aren’t reflected in explicit price rises are referred to as hidden inflation. Shrinkflation is one of the most prevalent types of hidden inflation. When businesses save expenses by selling a smaller product at the same price, this is known as shrinkflation. Customers essentially spend more money because they buy less merchandise for the same amount of money.

Inflation that is difficult to track with the CPI may also appear as qualitative changes. For instance, businesses may decide to scrimp on their production lines to provide less enduring products. Or they might add preservatives to produce that was previously sold as fresh to increase its shelf life.

The cost of living may increase as a result of these changes, even though the CPI does not account for them.

The Consumer Price Index is released by who?

The CPI is calculated by the Bureau of Labor Statistics using data acquired by BLS data collectors. The CPI is then released on a monthly (and occasionally biweekly) basis.

Exist any inflation indices besides the CPI?

Yes. The Producer Price Index (PPI), which measures inflation in the production process, the Employment Cost Index (ECI), which measures inflation in the labor market, the International Price Program (IPP), which measures inflation for imports and exports, and others are all released by the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Which Inflation Gauge Is Monitored by the Federal Reserve?

The Fed closely monitors the core Personal Consumption Expenditures Price Index (PCE) rather than the CPI in order to carry out its monetary policy duties. The Bureau of Economic Analysis released it as an indicator of inflation.


We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Related Articles

Microsoft investigates Outlook outage as users face issues


Microsoft investigates Outlook outage as users face issues In this article: MSFT...

Toshiba’s Bidder Set to Win Commitments for $10.6 Billion Loan


Toshiba’s Bidder Set to Win Commitments for $10.6 Billion Loan In this...

European Gas Slips on Ample Stockpiles, Milder Weather Outlook


European Gas Slips on Ample Stockpiles, Milder Weather Outlook In this article:...

Australia’s Venture Capital Deals Slide 30% From Record Year


Australia’s Venture Capital Deals Slide 30% From Record Year Australia’s Venture Capital...

Baidu Surges After Prepping ChatGPT-Style ‘Ernie’ Bot for March


Baidu Surges After Prepping ChatGPT-Style ‘Ernie’ Bot for March In this article:...

Vanguard Eyes Bigger Slice of Australia’s $2.3 Trillion Pensions


Vanguard Eyes Bigger Slice of Australia’s $2.3 Trillion Pensions In this article:...